Reviews

We have used Affordable Rentals on multiple occasions throughout the years. Their staff is friendly, professional and very easy to work with. The customer service is excellent - we had the pleasure of recently working with Tim. He made the whole process very easy and was very good to us. The cars are clean and in very good condition. They even have a package so your dog can travel in the car. Definitely recommend this company!

Amazing staff that was super helpful about visiting the island. The only way to go is to rent a Jeep with chairs and an ice chest. Fill'er up at the market and head out. Make sure you have at least 2 days to get it all in.

Affordable has great cars, prices and staff. Loved our Mini Cooper convertible. Great way to self tour Nantucket

Fantastic customer service and knowledgeable staff. They give you all the information you need to visit everything on the island and accurate time estimates for how long it will take. Rented a brand new fully loaded Ford Bronco for a very good price considering they are probably the only place with one on the island. Will definitely rent from them again.

So we rented a car from Affordable Rentals, and we had an amazing day touring the island. Unfortunately the fool who is writing this review got stuck in the sand at Eel Point.
Tim Mahoney who owns Cooks Cycle Shop and Affordable Rentals came out and pulled us out. He was a real good guy, and with a just a little chastising, still made me feel better. “We’re all only human” Thank you tim for understanding. (and being human!)